FINRA just fined First Trust Portfolios $10 million for six years for giving brokers courtside basketball tickets, concert passes, and luxury entertainment that exceeded gift limits.
Two wholesalers handed out $3,200 courtside seats more than 25 times. One broker received over $31,000 in tickets in 18 months. They tied hockey tickets to a $1 million sales quota. Then, they falsified expense records and sent fake reports to cover up the incident.
First Trust manages over $250 billion in assets. They have armies of wholesalers, massive marketing budgets, and resources that most boutiques can only imagine. And even with all that, they felt enough pressure to cross these lines.
That should tell you something about how intense the competition for distribution has become.
The Complaint You Always Hear
Discuss marketing with any boutique asset manager, and compliance will likely come up within the first five minutes. Can’t do this. Can’t say that. Can’t send gifts. Can’t host events without jumping through hoops. Marketing feels like trying to run with ankle weights.
The implicit message is always the same. If only compliance would get out of the way, we could compete with the big firms.
But the First Trust situation suggests something different.
The Pressure Everyone Feels
First Trust didn’t break these rules in a vacuum. The distribution game has gotten brutal. Bloomberg reported back in March that aggressive wholesaler tactics had become an open secret as smaller firms tried to compete with giants like Vanguard and BlackRock.
When you’re selling products in a crowded market where advisors have hundreds of options, the temptation to stand out through entertainment and perks becomes real. Add sales quotas and competitive pressure, and you can see how a firm might rationalize crossing lines that seemed minor at first.
The problem wasn’t unique to one firm. It’s what happens when companies compete on relationships built through entertainment instead of value.
What Happens Without the Rules
Imagine if FINRA eliminated the $100 gift limit tomorrow.
Within six months, wirehouses would be receiving Super Bowl tickets, all-expense-paid trips to Hawaii, and VIP experiences that are priceless. Distribution would turn into a spending contest, and some boutiques would be irrelevant before the year ended.
You think you can’t compete with BlackRock’s marketing budget now? Try competing with their entertainment budget when there are no rules in place.
Compliance rules aren’t holding you back. They’re preventing a competition you were never meant to win.
The Advantage That Actually Works
Here’s what advisors tell us they want: content they can use with clients and direct access to the people managing the money.
Not courtside seats. Not steak dinners. Those might help build rapport, but they don’t assist an advisor in explaining your strategy to a client during a meeting.
- What helps is consistency.
- Monthly commentary they can forward to clients
- Quarterly calls with your portfolio managers
- Direct email access when markets get volatile
- Webinars that explain your positioning
Large firms have wholesalers who can discuss products, but they don’t make investment decisions. You have portfolio managers who can. A $500 billion firm can’t scale personal access to its investment team. You can.
Start using that access to build habits that show how you think. A 500-word market update every Monday. Monthly deep dives on your positioning. Quarterly webinars where advisors can ask questions.
This doesn’t take a big budget. It takes consistency. And it builds something courtside seats never can. It builds trust in your investment process and the people behind it.
Why Some Boutiques Still Struggle
Not because of compliance. Because they’re not doing the things that work.
No regular content. No systematic advisor outreach. Maybe a quarterly letter, if anyone remembers. No webinars. No market updates. No proactive communication.
Then they blame compliance for why they’re invisible.
The reality is simpler and harder to accept. Most boutiques aren’t losing to entertainment budgets. They’re losing to inaction.
The Lesson
The pressure to compete on entertainment and perks is genuine. Even large, well-resourced firms feel it. However, that path leads to violations, fines, and relationships built on a flawed foundation.
Compliance forces everyone to compete on substance. For boutiques, it’s not a burden. It protects you from a spending war you’d lose and invites you to compete where you’re strongest.
You have advantages the giants can’t replicate. Too many boutiques still aren’t using them.
Stop waiting for compliance to get out of the way. Start building the content strategy and advisor relationships that win on merit.
That’s how you compete when the playing field is level.
Still Playing Defense?
If you’re ready to stop waiting for compliance to change and start building the kind of marketing that wins on substance, schedule a free strategy session. We’ll uncover what’s keeping advisors from calling you back and outline how to address the issue.
Dan Sondhelm is the CEO of Sondhelm Partners. He works with boutique asset managers to help them grow AUM, stand out in crowded markets, and create more meaningful conversations with investors.
Connect
